White Card Has Questions Too

Investor Group Issues Questions To The Trustees Of Texas Pacific Land Trust

White card appears to have pulled no punches here.

If I had to pick two, these are the questions I find most relevant to the subject of the Trustees acting as proper stewards of the trust.

Why did you threaten us with blocking every proposal Mr. Oliver might bring as trustee if we didn’t settle with you?  How is such a statement consistent with your role as fiduciaries?

Why have you almost quit retiring shares? This has been a key component and tax efficient way to create shareholder value for over 130 years.



We’ll See You in Dallas!

Investor Group Further Comments On Efforts Of Trustees Of Texas Pacific Land Trust To Delay Shareholder Vote

Strong statements from the White card who intends to make the vote happen on 5/22.

In your vehemence to win a proxy contest, you seem to have forgotten that as trustees of a 19th century-created trust, you can be held personally accountable for operating outside the narrow confines of the authority and delegation of power granted to you under a six-page deed from 1888.  By your own choice, you are not directors of a modern corporation with broad charter powers and expansive director exculpatory provisions.

Bottom line:

  • We believe there are no legitimate reasons for you to attempt to delay the shareholder vote on a new trustee — only excuses. 
  • Since March 4, 2019, when you nominated Preston Young, you have had an abundance of TIME to communicate your message to shareholders.
  • You have had an abundance of MONEY — the bank of shareholder capital expended for the most part in an impermissible manner in our view — to protect your lifetime trustee appointments. 
  • You have WITHHELD the NOBO list and directed your solicitors to bombard shareholders with evening solicitation phone calls. That was not enough.
  • You continue to SPEND lavishly on social media—Google, Twitter and Facebook ads—, on lawyers, ad agents, solicitors and private investigators, to spread your vicious character attacks on us, long-term shareholders who wish to propose more open governance. Your own senior executives have privately expressed their embarrassment at your tactics.
  • We believe most shareholders are simply tired of your messages and are ready to have their votes counted. 
  • We will see you at 10 am on May 22, 2019 in Dallas, Texas, and we intend that the holders present in person or by proxy at the special meeting will have a final say on this matter.

SoftVest Request Holders List

EDGAR: Request to Inspect and Copy Certain Records

Yesterday, a reader of the blog indicated that they received a call from ‘TPL’ to discuss the proxy and presumably sell BLUE.  Team WHITE is requesting the list so that they may do the same.

Anyone else get a call yet?

I am writing to formally request that you make available for inspection and copying to me and my representatives, during TPL’s usual business hours, the list of certificate holders of TPL showing the name, address, email address (if available), and number of Shares registered in the name of each such holder as of the close of business on March 28, 2019, which is the record date for the upcoming special meeting of holders of Shares currently scheduled for May 22, 2019 (the “Special Meeting”). I make this request pursuant to the express terms of Section Fourth of the Declaration of Trust of TPL and common law.
Further, on the same basis, I hereby request that you make available for inspection and copying a copy of the Depository Trust Company Omnibus Proxy, omnibus proxies from banks and brokerage firms and the list of non-objecting beneficial owners of Shares that TPL has recently requested from Broadridge Financial Solutions, Inc. As you know, such “NOBO” list includes the names of beneficial owners of Shares who hold through brokers and other custodians that have given permission to their financial intermediary to release their identity. TPL management obviously intends to use such information to solicit proxies from holders of Shares in connection with the Special Meeting. From a corporate governance perspective, we assume you recognize how important it is for TPL investors that SoftVest not be denied the same ability to make its case that management enjoys.

Letter from Eric Oliver

SoftVest, L.P., Horizon Kinetics LLC, and ART-FGT Family Partners Issue Letter to Shareholders of Texas Pacific Land Trust

Same Letter on EDGAR

The highlighting below is not mine; it is part of the original text.  No punches pulled here but all points are fair.  There is some drilling information in the letter that is new to me or perhaps presented in a different way; it’s exciting nonetheless.

Full text of letter:

Dear Fellow TPL Shareholder:

We are writing to seek your support for the election of Eric Oliver as trustee of Texas Pacific Land Trust (TPL) at the special meeting of shareholders to be held on May 22, 2019.

As you may know, TPL’s governing document gives shareholders the right to cast their vote on trustees only when one of the three seating trustees dies, resigns or is otherwise disqualified.  In fact, TPL has only held four shareholder meetings in thirty years.

The upcoming special meeting therefore is a unique opportunity for TPL investors to participate in the future direction of TPL. We encourage all TPL shareholders to cast their vote.

The undersigned are long-term holders of TPL shares, and currently hold in the aggregate over 25% of the outstanding TPL shares.  Although TPL’s management likes to refer to us as “dissidents” and “activists”, all of us are heavily vested and rooting for the success of TPL. And we strongly believe that Eric Oliver will work with the two incumbent Trustees to make TPL a more successful company.

We believe Mr. Oliver will introduce a fresh perspective from a long-term investor that has studied TPL for over ten years, and is committed and capable to roll up his sleeves and work collaboratively with his fellow Trustees.

The two incumbent Trustees will be presenting their own nominee at the special meeting.  And, unfortunately, until this time the Trustees and management seem more concerned about employing scare tactics and fear-mongering to get their nominee elected, than letting him explain what perspectives he offers to bring to TPL. We hope to see in the future more substantive discourse about the future of TPL.

We also hope that the two incumbent Trustees stop taking unqualified credit for the returns experienced by TPL investors the past few years. For that, we believe proper credit is due to the numerous exploration and production companies that have spent over $10 billion since 2013 drilling on TPL’s treasured royalties and land.  In fact, it is the 1,178 wells drilled between 2014-2018 (37.26 net lateral miles) that have increased the Trust’s oil production over 600% and its gas production close to 1,000%.  All investors may be interested to know there have been an additional 142 wells (5.0013 nlm) drilled year-to-date with 49 wells (1.46 nlm) currently drilling for another $1.5 billion spent so far this year, so we have good reason to believe the trend will continue. Being dealt a Royal Flush does not make one a good poker player.

We invite you to read the rest of this letter and our proxy statement for additional information about Eric Oliver and his commitment to TPL investors.


We believe that Mr. Oliver is an experienced oil and gas investor with over 22 years of experience buying and selling properties and over 35 years of experience managing investments with an emphasis in the energy market.

Among other relevant experience:

  • Mr. Oliver currently serves as the President of SoftVest Advisors, a registered investment adviser that acts as an investment manager for clients, including funds and managed accounts, with investments in oil and gas minerals and royalties.
  • Mr. Oliver was President of Midland Map Company, LLC, a Permian Basin oil and gas lease and ownership map producer since 1997, and recently sold in January 2019 to Drilling Info.
  • Mr. Oliver is Principal of Geologic Research Centers LLC, a log library providing geological data to the oil and gas industry with a library in Abilene, Texas.
  • Mr. Oliver has served on the Board of Directors of Texas Mutual Insurance Company since 2009, where he currently also serves as Chairman of the Investment Committee, with over $6,500,000,000 of total assets.
  • In 2007, through certain affiliated entities, Mr. Oliver led a team to successfully acquire the assets of the Santa Fe Energy Trust (formerly NYSE ticker SFF), which consisted of over 12,000 royalty and working interest properties in at least seven states.


Mr. Oliver believes that the Trust would benefit from converting into a Delaware corporation, and subject to his duties as trustee, Mr. Oliver is committed to fully exploring this alternative.

Among other things, we believe that, as compared to trust law, Delaware corporate law has a more well-developed legal framework around matters of governance and investor rights, which in our view provides greater comfort and predictability to investors in a publicly-traded entity.

We believe that fundamental principles of modern corporate governance demand that investors have a right to vote on their directors at least once a year.  In our view, life-tenured trustee positions do not have a place in a $6 billion market cap publicly-traded company.  

Investors in a public company should simply not be forced to think of a trustee’s or director’s tenure in terms of his or her life expectancy.


In June 2017, TPL announced the formation of Texas Pacific Water Resources LLC (TPWR), which focuses on providing a full-service water offering to operators in the Permian Basin.

We believe that TPWR’s activities could create various risks for TPL, such as risks related to workers compensation, leaks or rupturing of pipelines. In light of those risks, Mr. Oliver is committed to actively encouraging TPL to evaluate the existing water business and, with the assistance of outside consultants and other advisors, determine if it is advisable to grow operations internally, partner with a strategic partner, or sell the water rights to a third party and retain a royalty.

In addition, Mr. Oliver believes that any proposed capital expenditures and operating expenses incurred in connection with TPWR should have their respective expected rates of return carefully compared to the compounding benefits of retiring outstanding shares.


Mr. Oliver is also committed to a higher degree of transparency and more frequent updates to holders of TPL shares.

For example, we believe investors would benefit from drilling updates, drilled and uncompleted well updates, water production, water injection volumes, and engineering reports.

We look forward to engaging with many of you in the coming weeks.

Your vote at the upcoming special meeting of TPL shareholders is very important, no matter how many or how few shares you own.  Please sign, date and return the enclosed WHITE proxy card or voting instruction card today.

We thank you for your support.



If you have any questions regarding your WHITE proxy card please contact our proxy solicitor, D.F. King:

Holders may call toll-free: (800) 848-3416
Banks and brokers call: (212) 269-5550

E-mail: TPL@dfking.com


SoftVest, L.P. (“SoftVest LP”) has filed a definitive proxy statement (the “Proxy Statement”) with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) in connection with the solicitation of proxies for a special meeting of holders of the sub-share certificates of proprietary interests (the “Shares”) for the election of a new trustee of Texas Pacific Land Trust (“TPL”) to fill the vacancy created by the resignation of Maurice Meyer III (such meeting, together with any adjournments, postponements or continuations thereof, the “Special Meeting”). INVESTORS ARE STRONGLY ADVISED TO READ THE PROXY STATEMENT BECAUSE IT CONTAINS IMPORTANT INFORMATION. Investors may obtain a free copy of the proxy statement, any amendments or supplements thereto and other documents that SoftVest LP files with the SEC from the SEC’s website at www.sec.gov, or by contacting D.F. King, SoftVest LP’s proxy solicitor, by phone (212-269-5550) or e-mail (TPL@dfking.com).

SoftVest Advisors, LLC, SoftVest LP, Eric L. Oliver, ART-FGT Family Partners Limited, Tessler Family Limited Partnership, Allan R. Tessler, Horizon Kinetics LLC, Murray Stahl, Horizon Asset Management LLC, Kinetics Advisers, LLC, and Kinetics Asset Management LLC may be deemed participants in the solicitation of proxies from holders of Shares in connection with the matters to be considered at the Special Meeting. Information about such participants’ direct and indirect interests, by security holdings or otherwise, is contained in the Proxy Statement.

Edward McCarthy / Geoffrey Weinberg / Peter Aymar
D.F. King & Co., Inc.
(212) 269-5550

SOURCE SoftVest L.P.

White Proxy Finalized

SoftVest 14A

All SEC Filings

Overall very little change (that I can see) from the preliminary proxy materials filed on 4/5.

One add:

Important Notice Regarding the Availability of Proxy Materials for the Special Meeting — This Proxy Statement and our WHITE proxy card are available at: www.ViewMaterial.com/TPL


The following, to me, is the most important part of the filing:

We are soliciting your support to elect Mr. Oliver at the Special Meeting because we expect that he, as a trustee and subject to his duties as such, will encourage the other trustees and the Trust to (1) explore the Conversion, as well as any other opportunities available to maximize value for holders of Shares and (2) be more transparent and frequent on updates to holders of Shares (e.g., drilling updates, drilled and uncompleted well updates, water production, water injection volumes, and engineering reports). In that regard, we understand that if elected Mr. Oliver will be only one of three trustees, such that effecting any of the foregoing will require the agreement of one or both of the other trustees.