I’ve been fortunate to talk to a large number of TPL holders over the past month. Down to a person, the group is passionate about TPL and wants only the best (read: long term value maximization) for the Trust. Old and new investors alike have a great deal of reverence for the history of the trust. Another common refrain I hear from investors is that of TPL’s strong working culture and highly engaged team. So, in light the commonalities and positive attributes above, I suggest all sides come together and steer this proxy battle away from getting any uglier.
Middle ground proposal:
- In light of the wishes of a block that owns 25% of TPL, current Trustees Barry and Norris move to nominate and accept Eric Oliver as Trustee.
- Trustees (working together) nominate a 5-7 person Governance Exploration Committee. All members of the committee must be agreed upon by all three trustees.
- Governance Exploration committee works for a period of six months to determine and recommend a long-term path for TPL oversight that 1) is respectful of the long term past values and goals of the Trust and 2) reflects 21stcentury realities of both corporate governance and the magnitude of the opportunity in West Texas.
- New Governance form is brought to sub-unit holders for a go/no go vote
- No vote = back to the drawing board
- Yes vote = mandate to execute
It’s not perfect, but it represents a fair shake for all involved. There are probably many other solutions like it. The important part is that all sides come together and a solution is adopted.
The stakes are extremely high. Mistakes can cost billions. Let’s set TPL up for high quality strategic direction and decision making via improved governance NOW.
Resistance to come to a common-sense middle ground should be looked upon by investors with contempt. Personal ego, pride, and control should come AFTER doing the right thing for investors.
The horse is out of the barn, the cat is out of the bag, and we can never go home again. There will never be another day in the future where governance at TPL isn’t an issue. It must be resolved.